So I’m not sure if you’re all aware of this, but Marvel finally bit the bullet and did a big ol’ Marvel/Star Wars crossover… as in Marvel characters interact with Star Wars characters and vice versa. It’s a thing that could have been teased or poked fun of, but is actually happening.
This is, of course, to commemorate 50 years of Star Wars next year, with the big news being that you can watch the original theatrical Star Wars in theaters in February, which is probably the only thing that I can truly say is worth going out to overpay a billion dollars for a ticket. Yes, I’ve seen the Special Editions in ’97, but for some, those aren’t quite the same thing.
But back to Hope Assembles… that’s the name of this thing. It’s the best they could come up with, I suppose. I don’t know if I could come up with a better name. That’s why I’m not a marketing fellow. At the same time, however, I’m not sure I’d go along with a crossover between two properties that are too distinct and different from each other. It seems kind of silly, doesn’t it?
“But wait!” you say, “They did a crossover with Star Trek and X-Men years ago!”
Yeah… and that was kind of silly, too. But you know what? It also kind of worked in spite of itself. Because you had good writers who knew the material and gave it some reverence. I’m not sure that I could say the same for today’s Marvel bullpen, who, for the most part, haven’t wrote anything genuinely compelling in decades. I mean… I try reading a couple issues of whatever they’re doing nowadays and I’m like… “Eh.”
“B-But you need to read the whole thing or else you won’t get the context!”
No, fuck you. I don’t need to read a novel to know that I will like it. Used to be a time when a comic treated every issue as if it were their first one and told nice, short self-contained stories to get the reader into it before diving into the big multi-part story. Now individual issues are things they put out so that they’d be collected into trade paperbacks later down the road. More than likely, that’s how I’m probably going to read this desperation assemblage of hope. When it hits the trades…
That’s assuming I remember to do so… or even care to… it depends on the mood. Sometimes, I’d be like “No thanks.” But other times, I’d be like “Hey, it’s sold for a discount. Sure, why not?” More than likely, it’s the former. Sometimes, it can be the latter.
Right now… yeah, I’m not hopeful (no pun intended) that this is going to be top-tier storytelling. Again, the concept is kinda silly. But if it’s the good kind of silly – the kind that acknowledges that silliness and yet produces something compelling and fun – it could be a fun ride. The bad kind of silly – the one with meta-jokes and the typical “Disney humor” that has killed many movies because of its ill-fitting and tiresome nature – is what is going to sink this comic. Sadly, it’s the kind of silly I expect and the kind that the usual gang of idiots in the press (your Bleeding Cools, your Screen Rants, etc.) will hype up and praise to the high heavens, much like Dave Meltzer overrates AEW matches that he hates, but the crowd liked it so nine and three-quarter stars or whatever the fuck.
Great, now I’m railing on the Meltzer cries.
Thanks a lot, Marvel/Star Wars.